Home & HearthDAILY

Cast iron, stainless, nonstick or carbon steel: which pan for what?

Every kitchen seems to collect pans: a dented skillet from a roommate, a nonstick one that’s seen better days, maybe a heavy cast iron pan someone swore would change your life. They all look like they do the same job. They don’t, and picking the right one for tonight’s dinner makes cooking easier. This guide compares the four most common types in plain terms.

A black enameled cast-iron pot with a lid on a stovetop, in black and white

You don’t need a pan for every task. The goal is to know what each one is good at, so the few you own get used for the right jobs.

In this guide · 11 sections
  1. The short answer
  2. Cast iron: slow to heat, hard to beat for crust
  3. Carbon steel: lighter and quicker
  4. Stainless steel: the everyday workhorse
  5. Nonstick: easy, but mind the heat
  6. Match the pan to the meal
  7. Two habits that matter more than the pan
  8. If you only buy two
  9. Care cheat sheet
  10. Pan questions, answered
  11. Sources and further reading
Compared4 pan types
Needs seasoningCast iron, carbon steel
Watch the heatNonstick
Skill levelAny

The short answer

Here is the whole comparison in one table. The sections after it explain the reasoning and the care each pan needs, so you can match the pan to the meal instead of buying a fifth skillet that does what the first four already do.

Four pans at a glance
PanBest atTrade-offUpkeep
Cast ironDeep searing, baking, oven roasting, braisingHeavy and slow to heat; acidic foods wear down its seasoningSeasoning, hand washing, thorough drying
Carbon steelStir-frying, quick sears, eggs, crepesNeeds seasoning; reacts to how you treat itSeasoning, hand washing, thorough drying
Stainless steelEveryday sautéing, sauces, pan sauces, acidic dishesFood sticks if the pan or oil isn’t readyUsually the simplest; follow the maker’s instructions
NonstickEggs, delicate fish, easy cleanupCan’t take very high heat or an empty, hot panGentle heat, soft tools, no dry preheating

Cast iron: slow to heat, hard to beat for crust

Cast iron is thick and heavy, which is both its strength and its drawback. It takes a few minutes to heat up, but once it’s hot, it stays hot. Made In’s cookware guide says cast iron holds heat longer and keeps the surface hot when cold food hits the pan, which is why it is the usual choice for steaks, thick chops and a deep, brown crust. Its weight is real, too: the same source puts a 12-inch skillet at roughly 6 to 9 pounds.

It also goes from the stovetop to the oven, so it is a natural pan for cornbread, a roast chicken or a one-pan dinner that finishes in the oven. The University of Illinois Extension lists baking cornbread, stir-frying vegetables and searing fillets among the things it does well.

Where it struggles

Acid is the main enemy. The same Illinois Extension guide notes that acidic, high-moisture foods such as tomatoes absorb the most iron, and that the acid breaks down the seasoned surface, so the pan has to be re-seasoned more often. If you simmer tomato sauce for an hour every week, another pan will serve you better. A quick pan of tomatoes now and then is fine; just expect to refresh the seasoning sooner.

How to look after it

On soap, the extension sources aren’t in complete agreement: Maine says there is no clear consensus and that a small amount is fine if you rinse and dry the pan well, while Illinois recommends mild or diluted soap. The point both make is the same: avoid harsh detergents and large amounts.

Carbon steel: lighter and quicker

Carbon steel looks like a lighter cousin of cast iron, and it behaves like one too. Made In’s comparison lists a 12-inch carbon steel pan at 4.3 pounds against 8.2 pounds for a 12-inch cast iron skillet. The same source says carbon steel reaches searing temperature in about 90 seconds, against three to four minutes for cast iron, and that it reacts faster when you turn the flame up or down. These are the manufacturer’s figures, so treat them as a guide rather than a lab result. They explain why this is the pan professionals reach for in stir-fries and quick, hot sautés.

Chopped vegetables stir-frying in a wok with metal tongs and a spatula over a flame

Both materials build a natural nonstick layer the same way: thin coats of oil heated past their smoke point. So carbon steel needs seasoning and the same careful drying as cast iron. It gives up some heat retention in exchange for speed, so a steak will sear well, but the pan cools faster when you add a lot of cold food at once. If you cook stir-fries often, our guide to stir-fry basics explains how to get the most out of a wok or a wide pan.

Stainless steel: the everyday workhorse

A stainless steel skillet is the pan most home kitchens end up using the most. It doesn’t need seasoning, it can usually take acidic ingredients like tomatoes and lemon without a problem, and it develops the browned bits on the bottom that you can turn into a pan sauce with a splash of stock or wine. Check your pan’s own instructions for oven limits and dishwasher use, because they vary by maker.

Its weak spot is sticking, and that is mostly a matter of technique rather than a flaw in the pan. The usual practice is to heat the pan first, add the oil, then add the food and leave it alone until it releases by itself. Pale, wet or cold food from the fridge sticks more, so pat meat dry and let it sit out briefly before cooking. If you pull at a piece of chicken and it won’t move, it usually isn’t ready to turn yet.

Because a stainless pan needs no special care, it is a sensible first skillet if you only want to buy one. That is general cooking practice and our own view, not the result of any test.

Nonstick: easy, but mind the heat

Nonstick is the most forgiving pan for eggs, pancakes and delicate fish, and it cleans up in seconds. The price is a ceiling on heat.

Raw beef steaks seasoned with coarse salt searing in a dark nonstick pan with rosemary sprigs and a garlic clove

America’s Poison Centers says Teflon-type coatings start to break down above about 500°F, and warns that heating a dry, empty nonstick pan can get it very hot very quickly. Germany’s Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) gives a higher figure for the coating’s decomposition, about 360°C (680°F), and advises never to heat the pan empty, especially on gas and induction, which heat fast. The figures differ, but the advice agrees: cook on low to medium heat, keep the pan filled with food or oil, and ventilate. Overheated fumes can cause a short flu-like illness, polymer fume fever, whose symptoms usually clear within a day or two, and birds are far more sensitive, so keep pet birds out of the kitchen.

The BfR also notes that small particles from a scratched coating are not expected to harm health, because PTFE is inert and passes through the body unchanged. Even so, a pan whose coating is worn or peeling is not performing as it should, so follow the manufacturer’s guidance on when to replace it. Use wooden or silicone tools, wash by hand unless the maker says otherwise, and keep it away from open flames and grills.

Match the pan to the meal

If a recipe doesn’t say which pan to use, this table makes the choice quick.

Which pan for which dish
DishGood choicesWhy
Steak or thick chopCast iron, carbon steelBoth take very high heat and brown deeply
Stir-fryCarbon steel or a wide panFast heat response and easy to toss
Fried or scrambled eggsNonstick, seasoned carbon steelFood releases easily at moderate heat
Tomato sauce, lemon saucesStainless steelAcid wears down the seasoning on cast iron
Pan sauce after searingStainless steelBrowned bits dissolve into the liquid
Cornbread, oven roastsCast ironHolds heat and goes into the oven
Delicate fishNonstickThe skin and flesh are less likely to tear
Penne pasta in a creamy tomato-spiced sauce in a dark skillet on the stove

Two habits that matter more than the pan

Plenty of “sticking” and “steaming” problems come from how the pan is used, not from the pan. Dry meat browns, wet meat steams, so pat it dry with paper towels before it goes in. Preheat the pan so the food sizzles when it lands. And give each piece room, because crowding drops the temperature and the food stews in its own juices. The cooking-temperature basics are covered in our guide to the tools a home cook needs.

Fatih’s note Whatever pan I’m using, I dry the meat, preheat the pan and don’t crowd it. In my experience those three habits change the result more than the pan itself does.
Picture this Your fried eggs weld themselves to a stainless pan, and the first thought is that you need a new pan. Instead you wait for the pan to heat, add the oil, slide the eggs in and leave them alone. They release without help. (This is an example scenario, not a real story.)

If you only buy two

You don’t need all four. A practical pair for most households is a stainless steel skillet for everyday cooking and sauces, plus either a nonstick pan for eggs and fish or a cast iron skillet if you love a hard sear. Add carbon steel when you find yourself cooking stir-fries every week.

Fatih’s note I would rather own two pans I reach for every week than a rack of five I rarely use. A few good tools that you keep in good shape beat a big collection, and a kitchen with fewer pans is also easier to organize.

Before you buy a new one, run through three quick questions: how often will you use it, do you already own a pan that does the same job, and will it be easy to clean and store? If you can’t say yes to all three, wait.

Care cheat sheet

Quick care guide
PanWashAvoid
Cast ironHot water, soft brush, dry at once, light oilSoaking, dishwasher, steel wool, cold water on a hot pan
Carbon steelSame as cast ironSoaking and leaving it wet
Stainless steelWarm soapy water; follow the maker’s instructionsHeating an empty pan for long periods
NonstickBy hand with a soft sponge unless the maker allows the dishwasherHigh heat, empty preheating, metal tools, open flames

Pan questions, answered

Which pan is best for a beginner?

A stainless steel skillet is a reasonable first pan because it needs no seasoning and handles most foods. Add a nonstick pan if eggs and delicate fish are on your regular menu.

Can I cook tomato sauce in cast iron?

You can, but the University of Illinois Extension says acidic, high-moisture foods like tomatoes absorb the most iron and break down the seasoning, so the pan needs re-seasoning more often. For long simmers, stainless steel is easier.

Is it safe to use a scratched nonstick pan?

Germany’s BfR says particles from a scratched PTFE coating are not expected to harm health. A worn pan still won’t work as well, so follow the maker’s advice on replacing it.

At what temperature does nonstick coating break down?

America’s Poison Centers says Teflon-type coatings start to break down above about 500°F. The BfR gives about 360°C (680°F) for decomposition. Cook on low to medium heat and never heat the pan empty.

Is carbon steel the same as cast iron?

They are different materials but behave alike. Carbon steel is lighter and heats and cools faster, while cast iron is heavier and holds heat longer. Both need seasoning.

Can I put cast iron in the dishwasher?

No. The University of Illinois Extension and the University of Maine Cooperative Extension both say to keep cast iron out of the dishwasher, because it removes the seasoning and can rust the pan.

Sources and further reading

Cast iron seasoning and care follow the University of Maine Cooperative Extension’s Cast Iron Basics and the University of Illinois Extension’s guide to cast iron cookware. Weights, heat-up times and best uses for carbon steel and cast iron come from Made In’s carbon steel vs. cast iron comparison, a manufacturer, so those figures are the company’s own. Nonstick temperature limits and fume advice follow America’s Poison Centers’ “Teflon flu” article and the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment’s questions and answers on PTFE-coated cookware. The advice on stainless steel is general cooking practice and was not taken from a single source. Check each pan’s manufacturer instructions. “Fatih’s note” boxes are his own working habits.

Keep reading

All kitchen guides → · Browse every guide

↑